> On 30 Apr 2024, at 04:41, Jingxian Li <aqktjcm@qq.com> wrote:
> Attached is a patch that fixes bug when calling strncmp function, in
> which case the third argument (authmethod - strchr(authmethod, ' '))
> may be negative, which is not as expected..
The calculation is indeed incorrect, but the lack of complaints of it being
broken made me wonder why this exist in the first place. This dates back to
e7029b212755, just shy of 2 decades old, which added --auth with support for
strings with auth-options to ident and pam like --auth 'pam <servicename>' and
'ident sameuser'. Support for options to ident was removed in 01c1a12a5bb4 but
options to pam is still supported (although not documented), but was AFAICT
broken in commit 8a02339e9ba3 some 12 years ago with this strncmp().
- if (strncmp(authmethod, *p, (authmethod - strchr(authmethod, ' '))) == 0)
+ if (strncmp(authmethod, *p, (strchr(authmethod, ' ') - authmethod)) == 0)
This with compare "pam postgresql" with "pam" and not "pam " so the length
should be "(strchr(authmethod, ' ') - authmethod + 1)" since "pam " is a method
separate from "pam" in auth_methods_{host|local}. We don't want to allow "md5
" as that's not a method in the array of valid methods.
But, since it's been broken in all supported versions of postgres and has
AFAICT never been documented to exist, should we fix it or just remove it? We
don't support auth-options for any other methods, like clientcert to cert for
example. If we fix it we should also document that it works IMHO.
--
Daniel Gustafsson
