Re: Performance improvement for joins where outer side is unique - Mailing list pgsql-hackers

Hi, thanks for the new patch.

I made an additional shrink from your last one. Do you have a
look on the attached?

At Sun, 22 Mar 2015 19:42:21 +1300, David Rowley <dgrowleyml@gmail.com> wrote in
<CAApHDvrKwMmTwkXfn4uazYZA9jQL1c7UwBjBtuwFR69rqLVKfA@mail.gmail.com>
> On 20 March 2015 at 21:11, David Rowley <dgrowleyml@gmail.com> wrote:
> >
> > I can continue working on your patch if you like? Or are you planning to
> > go further with it?

It's fine that you continue to work on this.

# Sorry for the hardly baked patch which had left many things alone:(

> I've been working on this more over the weekend and I've re-factored things
> to allow LEFT JOINs to be properly marked as unique.
> I've also made changes to re-add support for detecting the uniqueness of
> sub-queries.

I don't see the point of calling mark_unique_joins for every
iteration on join_info_list in remove_useless_joins. 

The loop already iteraltes on whole the join_info_list so
mark_unique_join as an individual function is needless.

Finally, simply marking uniqueness of join in join_is_removable
seems to be enough, inhibiting early bailing out by the checks on
attribute usage and placeholder let it work as expected.

Reducing changes to this extent, I can easily see what is added
to planning computations. It consists of mainly two factors.

- Unique-join chekcs for every candidate inner joins in add_paths_to_joinrel.

- Uniqueness check of mergejoinable clause in join-removability check for every left join, some of which would be
skippedby other checks before.
 


> Also, I've added modified the costing for hash and nested loop joins to
> reduce the cost for unique inner joins to cost the join the same as it does
> for SEMI joins. This has tipped the scales on a few plans in the regression
> tests.

I've forgotten it, but quite important.

> Also, please see attached unijoin_analysis.patch. This just adds some code
> which spouts out notices when join nodes are initialised which states if
> the join is unique or not. Running the regression tests with this patch in
> places gives:
> 
> Unique Inner: Yes == 753 hits
> Unique Inner: No == 1430 hits
> 
> So it seems we can increase the speed of about 1 third of joins by about
> 10%.
> A quick scan of the "No"s seems to show quite a few cases which do not look
> that real world like. e.g cartesian join.

I don't have an idea how many queries in the reality hit this but
I suppose it's not a few.

> It would be great if someone could run some PostgreSQL application with
> these 2 patches applied, and then grep the logs for the Unique Inner
> results... Just to get a better idea of how many joins in a real world case
> will benefit from this patch.

Wow. I think the second patch should be DEBUGx, not NOTICE:)


regards,

-- 
Kyotaro Horiguchi
NTT Open Source Software Center